L2L Ledger to Ledger

Our services

Ledger to Ledger Transfers (L2L) 

We have to distinguish between two distinct types of ledger-to-ledger (L2L) transfers that warrant examination: one in the traditional banking sector and the other in the realm of blockchain technology.

In the context of traditional banking, L2L transfers involve the movement of assets, liabilities or equities between separate ledgers maintained by financial institutions, such as banks or payment service providers. These transfers can occur between accounts within the same institution or across different institutions and are crucial for facilitating secure and efficient transactions within the global financial system.

Conversely, L2L transfers within the blockchain sphere refer to the process of transferring value or assets between distinct distributed ledgers, such as different blockchain networks. This type of transfer often necessitates the utilization of specialized protocols, intermediaries, or techniques, such as atomic swaps or cross-chain bridges, to ensure interoperability and maintain the integrity of both ledgers involved.

Transactions as Adjustments in Ledgers in Banking

When a financial transaction occurs, such as a transfer of currency from one account to another, no physical movement of money takes place. Instead, the transaction is executed by adjusting the ledger entries in the respective accounts of correspondent banks, the central bank(s) or RTP clearing systems. The banking system decreases the balance in one account and increases the balance in another, reflecting the transfer of value to be settled separately.

Reconciliation and Final Settlement: The banks involved reconcile the transaction to ensure accuracy. In cases where intermediary banks are used, each bank settles its part of the transaction through their correspondent banking relationships.

Reporting and Record-Keeping: Banks maintain records of all transactions for compliance, auditing, and reporting purposes.

Ledger to Ledger (L2L) special Cases

Banking

Ledger-to-ledger (L2L) transfers in banking refer to the process of transferring assets, liabilities or equity between two separate ledgers maintained by financial institutions, such as banks or other payment service providers. These transfers can occur between accounts held within the same institution or across different institutions. In the context of banking, ledgers are centralized databases or record-keeping systems that track the ownership and transaction history of customer accounts and assets.

L2L transfers in banking are crucial for facilitating efficient and secure transactions between different financial entities and their customers. Here are some key aspects and examples of L2L transfers in banking:

  1. Interbank Transfers: Interbank transfers are a common form of L2L transfers in banking, where funds are moved between accounts held at different banks. These transfers can be facilitated through various mechanisms, such as wire transfers (e.g., SWIFT), Automated Clearing House (ACH) transactions, and Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) systems.
  2. Intra-bank Transfers: Intra-bank transfers occur when funds are moved between accounts held within the same financial institution. These L2L transfers are typically faster and may have lower fees compared to interbank transfers since they only involve updating the bank's internal ledgers.
  3. Central Bank Ledgers: Central banks maintain their own ledgers that track the reserve balances of commercial banks within their jurisdiction. L2L transfers between central bank ledgers and commercial bank ledgers are critical for managing reserve requirements, executing monetary policy, and facilitating interbank transactions.
  4. Cross-border Transfers: L2L transfers in banking also play a crucial role in cross-border transactions, where funds are moved between banks or financial institutions located in different countries. These transfers often involve currency conversion and may require the involvement of correspondent banks or international payment networks to facilitate the transaction.
  5. Digital Asset Transfers: With the growing adoption of digital assets and blockchain technology, some banks and financial institutions have started to explore L2L transfers involving digital assets or cryptocurrencies. These transfers may require the use of specialized protocols, such as the Interledger Protocol (ILP), or the development of new infrastructure, such as central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) or bank-backed stablecoins.

What can be transferred from Bank to Bank?

Bank Assets:

  1. Cash & Cash Equivalents: These are funds that can be accessed immediately or almost immediately. They include physical cash, deposits with other banks, and highly liquid securities like Treasury bills.
  2. Investments/Securities: These are financial instruments that the bank invests in to earn a return, such as government and corporate bonds, stocks, and other securities.
  3. Loans and Advances: These are the funds that a bank lends to its customers, and they generate interest income. They can include personal loans, mortgages, commercial loans, credit card balances, and overdrafts.
  4. Fixed Assets: These are physical properties owned by the bank, such as buildings, land, equipment, and furniture.
  5. Intangible Assets: These include non-physical assets like software, patents, trademarks, and goodwill.
  6. Other Assets: These can include accrued interest receivable, deferred tax assets, and derivative financial instruments among others.


Bank Liabilities:

  1. Deposits: These are funds that individuals and businesses keep in the bank. They include checking accounts, savings accounts, and time deposits. They are liabilities because the bank has an obligation to return these funds to the depositors on demand or at a specific maturity date.
  2. Borrowed Funds: These are funds that the bank borrows from other financial institutions, the central bank, or through issuing debt securities.
  3. Debt Securities: These are bonds or other forms of debt issued by the bank to raise funds. The bank is obligated to pay back the principal and interest to the bondholders.
  4. Other Liabilities: These include items like accrued expenses, accounts payable, deferred tax liabilities, provisions for loan losses, and derivative financial instruments.
  5. Subordinated Liabilities: These are debts that will only be paid after all other debts if the bank goes bankrupt.


Bank Equity:

  1. Common Stock: This is the equity that owners of the bank hold. They have voting rights and may receive dividends.
  2. Preferred Stock: This type of equity has a higher claim on earnings and assets than common stock but usually doesn't come with voting rights.
  3. Retained Earnings: These are the net earnings a bank has accumulated over the years and chosen to reinvest in the business rather than distribute as dividends.
  4. Treasury Stock: These are the bank's own shares that it has repurchased from the market.
  5. Other Comprehensive Income: These are gains and losses from various investments and derivatives that haven't been realized yet.
  6. Minority Interest: This is the part of the net assets of a subsidiary attributable to equity interests that are not owned, directly or indirectly through subsidiaries, by the parent.

Off-ledger to On-ledger

Transactions between banks, including off-ledger to on-ledger transactions, require additional steps to ensure the proper transfer of assets or liabilities, adherence to regulations, and proper accounting. 

The process is as follows:

  1. Identification of Transaction/Asset: The process begins with identifying the specific transaction or asset that needs to be moved from off-ledger to on-ledger. Both banks involved in the transaction must agree on the asset or liability to be transferred.
  2. Risk Assessment and Financial Analysis: Both banks will conduct their independent risk assessments and financial analysis. This is to ensure that the transaction aligns with their individual risk management policies and financial strategies.
  3. Interbank Agreement: Before the transaction can proceed, the banks must agree on the terms of the transfer. This may involve negotiation on the price of the asset or liability, the timing of the transfer, and other details. This agreement is often legally binding and must comply with local and international banking regulations.
  4. Regulatory Compliance: The transaction must comply with relevant banking regulations, including those related to capital adequacy, liquidity, and risk management. The compliance teams from both banks will work to ensure that the transaction meets these requirements. Compliance Frameworks: SOX (Sarbanes-Oxley Act): Ensures accuracy and integrity of corporate disclosures (U.S. specific) or GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation): Ensures the protection and privacy of client data, especially in the EU (Europe specific).
  5. Clearing and Settlement: Once the agreement is made and compliance is checked, the transaction proceeds to the clearing and settlement phase. This involves the actual transfer of the asset or liability from one bank's ledger to the other's. This process is often facilitated by a third-party clearing house, especially for large or complex transactions.
  6. Recording the Transaction: After the clearing and settlement process, each bank records the transaction on its own ledger. For the selling bank, the asset moves from on-ledger to off-ledger, and for the buying bank, the asset moves from off-ledger to on-ledger.
  7. Ongoing Management and Reporting: Both banks must manage and report the transaction on an ongoing basis. This involves tracking any changes in the value of the asset or liability, reporting these changes to the relevant regulatory authorities, and updating their individual financial statements accordingly.
  8. Continuous Monitoring: Finally, the banks continue to monitor the asset or liability on a regular basis to ensure that it remains in compliance with all relevant regulations and that its risk profile remains within each bank's risk tolerance.


The process of converting off-ledger funds to on-ledger funds involves transitioning assets that are not recorded on the bank's primary financial ledger into positions that are officially recognized on its books. This practice is primarily relevant in the context of shadow banking, asset management, or certain types of financial transactions that initially do not appear on the bank's main balance sheet. The intricate nuances of this procedure and the associated costs depend on regulatory frameworks, the nature of the assets involved, and the specific policies of the financial institution. Herein, we shall delineate the procedural steps typically entailed and expound upon the inherent costs.

Converting Off-Ledger Funds into On-Ledger Funds in Banks and Central Banks


Converting off-ledger sheet funds into on-ledger sheet funds involves integrating financial activities previously not recorded on the official balance sheet into the main accounting system. This is crucial for accurate financial reporting, transparency, and regulatory compliance. Below is a detailed breakdown of this process for both commercial banks and central banks, covering identification, verification, reconciliation, recording, and auditing.

A. Commercial Banks

1. Identification of Off-Balance Funds

Sources of Off-Ledger Funds:

  •  Special Purpose Entities (SPEs): Legal entities created for specific transactions, such as securitization, that can hold assets and liabilities off the bank’s main balance sheet. These may include structured investment vehicles (SIVs) and conduits.
  • Securitised Assets: Loans or receivables sold to investors but still serviced by the bank. Examples include mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and asset-backed securities (ABS).
  • Lease Obligations: Operating leases previously not capitalized under older accounting standards, but required to be included under new standards like IFRS 16.
  • Derivatives and Contingent Liabilities: Financial instruments such as swaps, futures, and options, as well as potential liabilities from guarantees and letters of credit.


2. Verification and Validation

Verification Steps:

  • Assessment of Financial Instruments: Detailed analysis to determine the nature, risk, and value of off-balance sheet items.
  • Valuation Models: Utilizing discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis, mark-to-market (MTM) valuations, and other financial models to assess the fair value of derivatives and securitized assets.
  • Credit Risk Analysis: Evaluating the creditworthiness of underlying assets and counterparties involved in OBS transactions.
  • Regulatory Review: Ensuring compliance with relevant accounting and regulatory standards.
  • IFRS 9 and IFRS 16: Governing the recognition and measurement of financial instruments and leases, respectively.
  • Basel III Framework: Risk-weighted assets (RWA) calculations and leverage ratios impacting the treatment of OBS exposures.


Protocols and Standards:

  • IFRS and GAAP: Ensuring consistent application of International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) for accurate financial reporting.
  • AML and KYC Compliance: Adhering to Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC) requirements to prevent illicit activities.


3. Reconciliation Process

Reconciliation Methodologies:

  • Detailed Transaction Review: Thorough examination and matching of off-balance sheet transactions with internal records.
  • Transaction-Level Matching: Ensuring each OBS item is accurately reflected and reconciled with corresponding on-balance sheet entries.
  • Exception Reporting: Identifying and resolving discrepancies through automated systems or manual intervention.


Tools and Software:

  • ERP Systems: Enterprise Resource Planning systems like SAP and Oracle Financials to automate reconciliation processes.
  • Specialized Reconciliation Software: Tools such as BlackLine and SmartStream for high-volume transaction matching and anomaly detection.


4. Recording in the General Ledger

Recording Methods:

  • Journal Entries: Detailed entries to incorporate OBS items into the general ledger, ensuring all relevant details are captured.
  • Automated Posting: Utilizing core banking systems to automate the recording of transactions, minimizing manual input errors.
  • Intercompany and Intrabank Entries: Ensuring proper accounting for transactions involving multiple entities within the banking group.


Protocols and Standards:

  • Double-Entry Accounting: Ensuring each transaction affects at least two accounts to maintain the accounting equation (Assets = Liabilities + Equity).
  • IFRS/GAAP Compliance: Adhering to international and national accounting standards to ensure transparency and consistency in financial reporting.


5. Audit and Compliance

Audit Processes:

  • Internal Audits: Regular internal reviews to ensure adherence to policies, procedures, and accuracy in financial reporting.
  • Continuous Monitoring: Implementing real-time audit systems to detect anomalies and ensure compliance continuously.
  • Risk-Based Audits: Focusing on high-risk areas such as derivatives and SPEs to ensure robust oversight.
  • External Audits: Independent verification by external auditors to ensure compliance with accounting standards and regulations.
  • Audit Trail Maintenance: Keeping comprehensive records of all transactions and adjustments to provide a clear audit trail.


Compliance Frameworks:

  • Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX): Ensuring accuracy and integrity of corporate disclosures (U.S. specific).
  • EU Audit Regulation: Ensuring accuracy and transparency of financial reporting in Europe.


Protocols and Technologies:

  • Regulatory Reporting Tools: Software like AxiomSL and Wolters Kluwer for preparing and submitting regulatory reports
  • Blockchain and DLT: Using Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) for immutable records and transparency in financial transactions.

 

B. Central Banks

1. Identification of Off-Balance Funds

Sources of Off-Balance Funds:

  • Foreign Exchange Reserves: Holdings of foreign currencies, gold, and Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) that may not be fully integrated into the balance sheet.
  • Contingent Liabilities: Guarantees, swap lines, and other potential obligations not recorded on the balance sheet.
  • Special Drawing Rights (SDRs): International reserve assets created by the IMF that central banks can hold off-balance.


2. Verification and Validation

Verification Steps:

  • Valuation of Reserves: Assessing the market value of foreign exchange reserves and other off-balance assets.
  • Market Prices and Exchange Rates: Using current market data to value reserves accurately.
  • Risk Assessment: Evaluating the credit and market risk associated with holding these reserves.
  • Regulatory Review: Ensuring compliance with international standards such as those set by the IMF.
  • IMF Guidelines: Adhering to the IMF’s Data Template on International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity.


Protocols and Standards:

  • IMF Standards: International Monetary Fund guidelines for reporting foreign exchange reserves and other monetary statistics.
  • Central Bank Accounting Standards: Specific standards and practices for central bank accounting and financial reporting.


3. Reconciliation Process

Reconciliation Methodologies:

  • Detailed Review of Holdings: Comparing records of foreign reserves and other off-balance items with actual holdings.
  • Ledger-to-Actual Matching: Ensuring the recorded data matches the physical or account balances.
  • Currency Reconciliation: Regularly reconciling foreign currency holdings against market rates and transactions.


Tools and Software:

  • Central Banking Systems: Customized software solutions for managing central bank transactions and holdings.
  • Specialized Reconciliation Tools: Tools designed for reconciling large volumes of foreign exchange transactions and reserves.


4. Recording in the General Ledger

Recording Methods:

  • Journal Entries: Detailed entries to reflect the integration of off-balance items into the general ledger.
  • Automated Systems: Utilizing central banking systems to automate the recording and updating of the general ledger.
  • Multi-Currency Accounting: Ensuring accurate accounting for transactions and holdings in multiple currencies.


Protocols and Standards:

  • Double-Entry Accounting: Maintaining balanced financial records through double-entry accounting.
  • IMF and Central Bank Standards: Adhering to international guidelines and specific central bank accounting standards.


5. Audit and Compliance

Audit Processes:

  • Internal Audits: Regular reviews to ensure accuracy and policy compliance within the central bank.
  • Real-Time Monitoring: Implementing systems for continuous monitoring and real-time audit capabilities.
  • Risk-Based Approaches: Focusing on areas with significant risk exposure, such as foreign reserves and contingent liabilities.
  • External Audits: Independent audits to ensure adherence to international standards and transparency in reporting.
  • Comprehensive Documentation: Maintaining detailed records of all transactions and adjustments for audit purposes.


Compliance Frameworks:

  • IMF Guidelines: Ensuring transparency and accuracy in reporting international reserves and foreign currency liquidity.
  • Central Bank Regulations: Adhering to specific regulatory requirements for central banks, including Basel guidelines for central banking.


Protocols and Technologies:

  • Blockchain and DLT: Enhancing transparency and accuracy through immutable records and distributed ledger technologies.
  • Regulatory Reporting Tools: Facilitating accurate and timely preparation and submission of regulatory reports.


Conclusion
The conversion of off-ledger funds into on-ledger funds is a detailed and multifaceted process requiring careful identification, verification, reconciliation, recording, and auditing. Both commercial banks and central banks must adhere to rigorous standards and protocols to ensure the accuracy, transparency, and regulatory compliance of their financial statements. By leveraging advanced tools and adhering to international standards, these institutions can effectively manage the integration of off-balance sheet items into their main accounting systems, ensuring the integrity of their financial reporting.

Inherent Costs

Quantifying the costs associated with converting off-ledger funds to on-ledger funds presents a complex challenge, given the myriad factors influencing these expenses. These factors include the nature and complexity of the assets involved, the jurisdictional regulatory requirements, and the financial institution's internal capabilities and resources. Nevertheless, an attempt to offer a more concrete estimation necessitates segmenting the costs into distinct categories and providing a range of potential expenses based on industry norms and available data.

  1. Compliance and Legal Fees
  • Initial Assessment and Due Diligence: $10,000 to $100,000+, depending on the asset's complexity and the due diligence depth required to ensure compliance with AML, KYC, and other regulatory standards like Basle III.
  • Ongoing Compliance: 0.1% to 0.5% of the asset's value annually, covering continued compliance monitoring and reporting.

2. Valuation and Auditing Expenses

  • Valuation Services: $5,000 to $50,000+ per asset, varying significantly with the asset's nature (e.g., real estate, private equity) and the valuation complexity.
  • Auditing Services: $15,000 to $200,000+, depending on the audit's scope required to integrate the assets into the financial statements officially.

3. Risk Management Costs

  • Risk Assessment Implementatio*: $25,000 to $100,000 for the development and integration of risk assessment models tailored to the specific asset types being brought on-ledger.
  • Ongoing Risk Management: 0.05% to 0.2% of the asset's value annually for continuous risk monitoring and management.

4. Capital Requirements

  • Additional Capital Reserves: This cost is more notional and depends on regulatory capital adequacy requirements. If integrating off-ledger assets increases the risk-weighted assets, the bank may need to hold additional capital, potentially 4% to 12% of the assets' value, based on Basel III minimum capital requirements.

5. Operational Adjustments

  • System and Process Integration: $50,000 to $500,000+, significantly influenced by the need for new software, system adjustments, or process redesign to accommodate the assets on the ledger.
  • Training and Staffing: $10,000 to $100,000 for training staff on managing and reporting the newly on-ledger assets and potentially higher for additional staffing needs.


Aggregate Cost Estimation
Given these categories, the initial conversion of off-ledger funds to on-ledger could realistically range from a few hundred thousand dollars to several million dollars for a single asset or a portfolio of assets. This estimate excludes the ongoing annual costs related to compliance, risk management, and possibly increased capital reserves, which could amount to a significant percentage of the asset's value. It's crucial to note that these estimates are highly generalized and would need to be refined based on specific asset types, regulatory jurisdictions, and institutional capabilities. For precise estimations, engaging with financial, legal, and compliance experts familiar with the specific context of the assets and regulatory environment is advisable.


In conclusion, the conversion of off-ledger funds to on-ledger funds is a multifaceted process, enveloped in stringent regulatory compliance, meticulous valuation, and comprehensive risk assessment. The costs inherent in this conversion are substantial, spanning legal, valuation, risk management, capital allocation, and operational domains. Each step and associated cost necessitates careful consideration to ensure the integration enhances the bank's financial health without compromising regulatory compliance or operational efficiency.



If you want to know more about how to transfer funds to your accounts with us, please get in contact with Marie Mayer.